Home Lex Fridman Episode
Lex Fridman · 2020-09-08

David Fravor: UFOs, Aliens, Fighter Jets, and Aerospace Engineering | Lex Fridman Podcast #122

Navy commander David Fravor recounts chasing the 2004 Tic Tac UFO and argues it should inspire a leap in propulsion science.

David Fravor: UFOs, Aliens, Fighter Jets, and Aerospace Engineering | Lex Fridman Podcast #122
The guest

David Fravor: Retired U.S. Navy pilot of 18 years and former commander of Strike Fighter Squadron 41 (the Black Aces). He is the lead eyewitness pilot of the 2004 USS Nimitz 'Tic Tac' UFO incident, widely considered one of the most credible UFO sightings on record.

What this episode covers

Fravor walks Lex Fridman through his path from enlisted Marine to Top Gun graduate and squadron commander, explaining the craft of flying, crew coordination, and the 80-percent-solution decision-making of dogfighting. The bulk of the conversation is a detailed first-person account of the November 2004 Tic Tac encounter off the California coast, the FLIR video shot by Chad Underwood, and the rumors about confiscated tapes. Fravor pushes back on debunkers like Mick West and stresses the sighting's credibility rests on four trained observers seeing it in clear daylight. He then pivots to speculation about advanced propulsion, government secrecy, and how private money like Musk, Bezos, and the Gates Foundation might crack such technology faster than the defense bureaucracy. The episode closes on mortality, kindness, family, and following your dreams.

Recommended on this episode

MediaRecommended

Cast Away

Robert Zemeckis

“i love the movie castaway”
“whatever you think of it i love the movie castaway with tom hanks and the idea of spending time on an island alone”— Lex Fridman
BookRecommendedISBN verified

Introduction to Algorithms (CLRS)

Cormen, Leiserson, Rivest, Stein

“i find algorithms beautiful like a little toolbox”
“the introduction to algorithms book also called clrs for the first letters of the last name of its four authors i find algorithms beautiful”— Lex Fridman
BookRecommendedISBN verified

Proving Einstein Right

S. James Gates Jr. and Cathie Pelletier

“there's a great book that i recommend people read”
“there's a great book that i recommend people read called proving einstein right by jim gates that talks about the hard work that people try to do”— David Fravor

Also referenced (named, not recommended)

MediaReferenced

Top Gun

Tony Scott

“let me ask the most ridiculous question how realistic is the movie top gun”— Lex Fridman
MediaReferenced

A League of Their Own

Penny Marshall

“kind of the quote from tom hanks and the girls baseball movie where he goes there's no crying in baseball”— David Fravor
MediaReferenced

Men in Black

Barry Sonnenfeld

“the movies became and it was men in black aliens uh independence day definitely gonna catch some shit”— David Fravor
MediaReferenced

Aliens

James Cameron

“the movies became and it was men in black aliens uh independence day definitely gonna catch some shit”— David Fravor
MediaReferenced

Independence Day

Roland Emmerich

“the movies became and it was men in black aliens uh independence day definitely gonna catch some shit”— David Fravor
ProductReferenced

LEGO Apollo Saturn V and Lunar Lander

LEGO

“i'm obsessed matter of fact i have the giant lego apollo at home and the lander and i have one that my dad built me in 1969”— David Fravor
MediaReferenced

American Made

Doug Liman

“it's the tom cruise movie what is it air america or whatever but he plays the guy in louisiana who was hauling drugs for pablo escobar”— David Fravor
MediaReferenced

Ancient Aliens

History Channel

“everyone has a theory you know ancient aliens covers all kinds of theories you know it's kind of off of oh my god”— David Fravor
MediaReferenced

Unidentified: Inside America's UFO Investigation

To the Stars Academy

“couple that with because they've got the series unidentified couple that with television to get the word out”— David Fravor
MediaReferenced

The Man in the High Castle

Amazon

“the man in the high tower whatever it's a netflix show where nazi actually wins it”— David Fravor

Big reveals from this episode

  • Fravor confirms there is no video from his own jet during the encounter; the Tic Tac was witnessed by all four sets of eyeballs across two F-18s.
  • He describes the object as a 40-foot smooth white Tic Tac with no wings, no propulsion plume, and no rotor wash, moving abruptly left-right with no inertia.
  • As he cut across the circle to intercept, the object accelerated and vanished in under half a second, then reappeared 60 miles away at the squadron's secret CAP point.
  • The radar in Chad Underwood's jet registered active jamming when locking the object, which Fravor notes is technically an act of war.
  • He recounts marching down to CVIC and threatening a junior officer to get his classified tapes back, calling the men-in-suits confiscation story a shipboard joke.
  • Asked to bet, Fravor says he does not think humans developed it, leaning toward it not being from this world while avoiding 'little green men' framing.
  • He explains why the military did not freak out: nobody would test a secret 'cool new toy' around unwitting pilots in a live exercise area.
  • He says revealing real Roswell wreckage, if it exists, could trigger a 10-to-20-year explosion of innovation and unite a divided world.

Worth remembering

  • Every real Top Gun graduate is on a logged list, and authentic patches are controlled because so many people falsely claim to have attended.
  • Fravor's core flying philosophy is the '80 percent solution', acting fast on a good-enough answer rather than overthinking in a fast chess game at 400 knots.
  • In the analog A-6 they flew 500-1000 feet through mountains at night at 7-8 miles a minute, navigating off a tiny Atari-like CRT radar screen.
  • On AI versus pilots: AI operates in black-and-white logic, while humans exploit gray areas like intentionally departing controlled flight for advantage.
  • The highest anxiety and heart rates measured in Vietnam pilots came not from combat but from landing on an aircraft carrier at night.
  • Humans think in 2D and want to flatten out; the real fighter advantage comes from working the vertical, where a super hornet split-S takes only ~2,500 feet.
  • Fravor names the SR-71 the greatest plane ever, built in the 50s by Kelly Johnson with titanium the CIA covertly bought from Russia via shell companies.
  • He pushed a clean super hornet to Mach 1.78 off Pebble Beach, realizing at that speed ejection would kill him because there is no out.
  • At least 60 people saw these objects on radar off the East Coast, prompting a NOTAM warning to airmen.
  • Fravor's grandfather, a beer delivery man, had a funeral procession three miles long; his lesson that no one is better than anyone else anchors the episode.