Home Lex Fridman Episode
Lex Fridman · 2020-01-21

Paul Krugman: Economics of Innovation, Automation, Safety Nets & UBI | Lex Fridman Podcast #67

Nobel laureate Paul Krugman argues automation isn't killing jobs, the US safety net is needlessly cruel, and politics shapes the economy.

Paul Krugman: Economics of Innovation, Automation, Safety Nets & UBI | Lex Fridman Podcast #67
The guest

Paul Krugman: Nobel Prize-winning economist, professor at CUNY, and New York Times columnist known for work on international trade, economic geography, and liquidity traps. He is also a prominent and outspoken commentator on the intersection of economics and politics.

What this episode covers

Lex Fridman talks with economist Paul Krugman about what a just and well-functioning economy looks like, from safety nets and the welfare state to the limits of markets and competition. Krugman argues the US has produced a uniquely cruel society for a rich nation, especially in healthcare and support for children. He pushes back hard on the popular narrative that automation and robots are destroying jobs, pointing to slow productivity growth and arguing wage stagnation is largely political. The conversation also covers universal basic income, international trade and the China trade war, the reliability of economic theory versus physics, and the value of public infrastructure investment.

Recommended on this episode

MediaRecommended

The Expanse

Syfy

“I'm a big fan of the TV series the expanse”
“I'm a big fan of the TV series the expanse and it's kind of gratifying that out there they the it's the Martian congressional republic”— guest

Also referenced (named, not recommended)

ProductReferenced

Consumer Reports

Consumer Reports

“if I'm buying a car I can actually probably do a pretty good job of looking up you know going to consumer reports reviews”— guest
BookReferencedISBN verified

The Wealth of Nations

Adam Smith

“let me leave you some words from Adam Smith in the wealth of nations one of the most influential philosophers and economists in our history”— Lex Fridman

Big reveals from this episode

  • Krugman says America has 'somehow managed to produce a crueler society than almost any other wealthy country for no good reason.'
  • He declares himself a 'tech skeptic,' calling the idea that we live through unprecedented technological change 'really an illusion.'
  • He argues automation is NOT taking jobs because productivity growth has actually slowed, the opposite of what mass automation would show.
  • Claims wage stagnation is fundamentally political, tied to the collapse of unions, not an inevitable force of technology.
  • Rejects universal basic income, saying it's either too low to live on or enormously expensive, and prefers expanding existing safety-net programs.
  • Says no serious center-right economists have any role in the Trump administration, which 'only want to listen to people who are cranks.'
  • On the China trade war, argues it's driven by the 'fundamentally wrong notion' that selling to China is good and buying is bad.

Worth remembering

  • Cites Kenneth Arrow's 1963 paper showing healthcare fails on every condition needed for competition to work.
  • Frames two views of justice: Rawls's outcome-based 'veil of ignorance' versus a process view based on absence of coercion.
  • Notes a card-carrying economist accepts incentives matter, but the evidence points 'considerably to the left' of most politicians.
  • Observes that people love government-run Medicare so much some say 'don't let the government get its hands on Medicare.'
  • Containerization quietly destroyed thousands of longshoreman jobs using giant cranes, not high-tech robots.
  • Two-thirds of Danish workers are unionized despite facing the same technology and global economy as the US.
  • Roughly 70-80 percent of growth in per capita income comes from the advance of knowledge, not capital accumulation.
  • Highlights the humble invention of the cardboard box as a foundational technology behind all Amazon deliveries.
  • Says a minimum wage of $12 seems safe based on evidence, while $15 and above enters genuine uncertainty.
  • Krugman jokes he is 'the king of hate mail' and worries if a column doesn't trigger a wave of it, he wasted the day.