Home Lex Fridman Episode
Lex Fridman · 2021-10-20

Brian Greene: Quantum Gravity, The Big Bang, Aliens, Death, and Meaning | Lex Fridman Podcast #232

Physicist Brian Greene unpacks quantum gravity, the Big Bang, consciousness, free will, aliens, and how mortality gives a meaningless universe its meaning.

Brian Greene: Quantum Gravity, The Big Bang, Aliens, Death, and Meaning | Lex Fridman Podcast #232
The guest

Brian Greene: Theoretical physicist at Columbia University and a leading string theory researcher. Bestselling author of physics books including The Elegant Universe and Until the End of Time.

What this episode covers

Brian Greene joins Lex Fridman for a wide-ranging conversation on physics and meaning. He argues that although the second law of thermodynamics dooms the universe to disorder, our brief ordered existence is cause for wonder, and that meaning is something each person creates rather than discovers. The discussion moves through the hard problem of consciousness, the status of string theory and quantum gravity, time as possibly emergent, time travel, the Big Bang and inflationary cosmology, dark energy, and the Fermi paradox. It closes on free will, the colonization of Mars, and the idea that the terror of death is the hidden engine of human creativity and consciousness.

Recommended on this episode

BookRecommendedISBN verified

The Denial of Death

Ernest Becker

“wonderful book that had a great influence in me”
“there's this wonderful book that had a great influence in me called the denial of death by ernest becker”— Brian Greene

The guest's own work

BookBy the guestISBN verified

Until the End of Time: Mind, Matter, and Our Search for Meaning in an Evolving Universe

Brian Greene

“in your most recent book until the end of time you quote bertrand russell from a debate he had about god in 1948”— Lex Fridman

Also referenced (named, not recommended)

BookReferenced

What Is Life?

Erwin Schrodinger

“schroedinger wrote the book what is life based on the few lectures he gave in 1944 so let me ask the fundamental question here what is life”— Lex Fridman
BookReferencedISBN verified

On the Road

Jack Kerouac

“kerouac jack carrack talked about this and on the road is you know when you leave a place if you're honest about it like life is short”— Lex Fridman
MediaReferenced

Star Trek

Gene Roddenberry

“as a kid i love star trek i just love the idea that we would be part of some universal community”— Brian Greene
MediaReferenced

The Twilight Zone

Rod Serling

“one of my favorite twilight zone episodes i don't ever saw this one where this alien civilization finally comes to planet earth”— Brian Greene
MediaReferenced

Contact

Robert Zemeckis

“this idea of a wormhole like jody foster and contact went through a wormhole deep space nine star”— Brian Greene
MediaReferenced

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine

Rick Berman

“jody foster and contact went through a wormhole deep space nine star i'm sure there are many other examples”— Brian Greene
MediaReferenced

Interstellar

Christopher Nolan

“if we're not trying to do things like build wormholes the way they did say an interstellar to get to a different place”— Brian Greene

Big reveals from this episode

  • Greene says searching for a universal meaning of life is a fool's errand because the universe has no emotional content; meaning is what each individual makes.
  • He predicts the mystery of consciousness will evaporate once we build artificial systems that report inner feelings.
  • He pushes back on the claim that string theory has fallen out of favor, arguing it is a vibrant field still scoring high on foundational progress.
  • Greene says string theory is too speculative for a Nobel and should really be called the 'string hypothesis' since theory means best available explanation.
  • He states traditional free will has no basis in physics, but a real freedom comes from our vast behavioral repertoire versus a rock's.
  • He admits inflationary cosmology has issues and that, unlike a few years ago, he no longer defends it as confidently.
  • On aliens, Greene believes many civilizations far more advanced than us exist and wouldn't bother hiding from us.
  • He proposes that consciousness and suffering only make sense in the context of death, so an AI may need existential dread to fit in.

Worth remembering

  • The second law of thermodynamics guarantees entropy always rises in aggregate, making us exquisitely ordered configurations lasting only a cosmic blink.
  • Without the asteroid that wiped out the dinosaurs 65 million years ago, conscious mammals like us might never have arisen.
  • Feynman argued that understanding where a rose's color and aroma come from only augments wonder rather than flattening it.
  • Near-light-speed travel could let you step out of a ship one million years in Earth's future, with no scientific dispute about it.
  • Wormholes are permitted by Einstein's equations, but propping one open may require exotic matter that might not exist.
  • We understand physics from about a millionth of a second after the Big Bang onward, but earlier than that remains hotly contested.
  • The amount of dark energy, in quantum-gravity units, is a decimal point followed by about 120 zeros and a one.
  • Estimates suggest roughly one planet per star, implying hundreds of billions of hundreds of billions of planets.
  • Terror management experiments show subtly reminding people of death (e.g. interviewing near a funeral home) measurably changes their behavior.
  • Greene notes that on the scale of eternity any finite duration is effectively zero, so even a robust AI must reckon with its own finitude.