Home Joe Rogan Episode
Joe Rogan · 2025-03-13

Joe Rogan Experience #2289 - Darryl Cooper

Storyteller Darryl Cooper joins Joe Rogan to defend nuanced history-telling and unpack how ordinary people get swept into atrocity.

Joe Rogan Experience #2289 - Darryl Cooper
The guest

Darryl Cooper: Host of the long-form history podcast Martyr Made, known for deeply empathetic deep-dive series on Jonestown, Israel-Palestine, and WWII. He drew major backlash after a controversial Tucker Carlson interview about Churchill and the origins of WWII.

What this episode covers

Joe and Darryl open on UFC before pivoting to the firestorm over Darryl's Tucker Carlson interview, where critics labeled him a Nazi apologist. Darryl explains his method: refusing to write about anyone until he can understand their actions on human terms, which brings him to the edge of empathizing with people society calls evil. The bulk of the conversation is a sweeping history seminar covering Hitler's radicalization in Vienna, WWI trauma, the American labor movement, immigration and national identity, the rise of cults like Jonestown, the 1960s protest movements, and how industrialization and slavery emerged from game-theory-like pressures. Throughout, they argue that reductive, outrage-driven culture destroys the nuance needed to actually learn from history.

Recommended on this episode

BookRecommended

Hitler (biography)

Ian Kershaw

“is a great book he's a good historian an excellent writer”
“the most recent sort of great Hitler biography by Ian Kershaw is a great book he's a good historian an excellent writer”— Darryl Cooper
MediaRecommended

Hardcore History: Blueprint for Armageddon (World War I series)

Dan Carlin

“probably my favorite piece of audio it's so good”
“Dan carin's series on World War I is like probably my favorite piece of audio it's so good”— Darryl Cooper
MediaRecommended

Hardcore History: Wrath of the Khans (Genghis Khan / Mongols series)

Dan Carlin

“I'm a giant fan of Dan's series on Genghis Khan and the Mongols”
“I'm a giant fan of Dan's series on D jangus Khan and the the Mongols just try to imagine living in a time”— Joe Rogan
MediaRecommended

American Primeval

Netflix

“it's amazing dude”
“you seen that new Netflix series uh American primeval it's amazing dude and Peter ber on here”— Joe Rogan
MediaRecommended

Wild Wild Country

Netflix

“incredible dude”
“wild wild country I'm sure you've seen that incredible dude my uh my grandmother it's my uncle's mom”— Joe Rogan

The guest's own work

MediaBy the guest

Fear and Loathing in the New Jerusalem

Darryl Cooper

“listen to Fear and Loathing in the New Jerusalem listen to it just you don't even have to listen to the whole thing listen to the first hour”— Darryl Cooper
MediaBy the guest

Martyr Made

Darryl Cooper

“it's martyr made it's available everywhere uh Audio Only so yeah I don't want to make people stare at my ugly mug”— Darryl Cooper

Also referenced (named, not recommended)

BookReferencedISBN verified

Mein Kampf

Adolf Hitler

“if you take him at his word in mcom which is you know it's a piece of political propaganda you know that he wrote”— Darryl Cooper
MediaReferenced

Holy Hell

Will Allen

“have you seen the documentary I'm like oh no this documentary and then you watch the documentary and that's what it was it was a guy who was a gay porn star”— Joe Rogan
MediaReferenced

Roger & Me

Michael Moore

“the whole Flint Miss Michigan thing Michael Moore's documentary um Roger and me it's it's one of those things”— Joe Rogan
MediaReferenced

Peaky Blinders

BBC

“they do a great job in peaky blinders of highlighting that like the streets are gray everything's a dull dark gray”— Joe Rogan
MediaReferenced

Gangs of New York

Martin Scorsese

“then you have mass massive organized crime violent horrific Gangs of New York style organized crime all throughout your city”— Joe Rogan
MediaReferenced

The Trojan Women

Euripides

“an early example of like that type of postmodernism is uh Ides play in ancient Greece the Trojan women”— Darryl Cooper
BookReferenced

The Iliad

Homer

“everybody knew the Iliad they knew the story of the conquest of Troy and all that but he wrote uh the story from the perspective of the women”— Darryl Cooper

Big reveals from this episode

  • Darryl admits his Tucker interview could have been clearer and that he likes to provoke his English friend with critical Churchill takes.
  • Darryl argues Churchill helped turn the German invasion of Poland into WWII, and questions whether the war's 40 million deaths were a cost worth paying.
  • Claims his Tucker points were all about events a full year before the June 1941 invasion of the USSR, where most Jews lived, suggesting Hitler had no access to them before that.
  • Notes Hitler had to phone Goebbels to stop Kristallnacht because Germans were outraged and it was bad propaganda, not out of love for Jews.
  • Darryl tells a long, graphic self-deprecating story about pounding a Starbucks coffee, breaking into a friend's balcony, and a stairwell accident to illustrate that history is made by people improvising in crisis.
  • Argues Jim Jones would be remembered as a civil rights hero had he died in 1962, before the cult turned deadly.
  • Joe predicts future generations will view factory farming the way we view slaveholding.
  • Darryl frames the transatlantic slave trade as a game-theory problem where any ruler who abstained would simply be conquered and enslaved anyway.

Worth remembering

  • Darryl's Jonestown series runs seven episodes and about 35 hours.
  • On the first day of the Battle of the Somme, the British lost 60,000 men.
  • In the American Primeval era, the Mormons were a genuinely dangerous, ultra-cohesive armed force.
  • Ireland is reportedly on track to be minority Irish by around 2070.
  • In the 1850s-60s, immigrant Irish dock workers on the East Coast had a life expectancy of about 14 years from stepping off the boat.
  • Colorado's National Guard once opened fire on a strikers' camp, killing around 22 women and children.
  • An active-duty IDF soldier emailed Darryl saying his podcast changed how he treats Palestinians daily.
  • Oxytocin increases trust and empathy toward your in-group while increasing distrust toward outsiders.
  • Jim Jones spent his last ~10 years on daily amphetamines to wake and barbiturates to sleep, fueling paranoia.
  • Some English churches reportedly still had the skins of Danish raiders nailed to their doors a hundred years into America's settlement.